electricity infrastructure

Electricity Infrastructure

VoxDevLit

Published 15.05.25
Co-editors
View Chapter:
Downloads:
Download
Cite
Robyn Meeks, Meera Mahadevan, “Electricity Infrastructure” VoxDevLit, 15(1), May 2025.
Citation copied to clipboard!
Chapter 7
Conclusion: Takeaways & evidence gaps

This review highlights the multidimensional nature of electricity infrastructure and how, despite international focus on expanding electricity access, this is only one piece of a broader, interconnected system. Much of the existing literature focuses on the socioeconomic and development impacts of new connections and the results are generally positive or null. The heterogeneity in the results is thought to be shaped by contextual factors including local economic conditions of the place being electrified and investment in complementary infrastructure, but there is a continued need to better understand the mechanisms driving the different results.

One major challenge in studying the impacts of electricity infrastructure is isolating the causal effects given infrastructure placement is almost always endogenous. In lieu of randomising infrastructure placement, much of the literature has relied on other empirical strategies to estimate causality. Although papers using these different methods have each provided valuable insight, they also come with limitations. Despite the challenges of randomisation, recent research has succeeded in randomising smaller scale infrastructure investments (i.e. smart meters, prepaid meters, and household connections to the transformer). Such efforts provide new opportunities for experimental research on electricity infrastructure. Given significant recent advances in data availability, remote monitoring technologies, and machine learning, there is great potential for future study of electricity infrastructure and its impacts.

Off-grid electricity is playing a major role in expanding energy access to the hardest-to-reach populations across the globe, especially in places where grid extension is too expensive or physically infeasible. While mini-grids have the potential to accelerate electrification efforts, research highlights that a number of challenges remain related to low demand, high costs, and uncertainties about integration in the face of eventual grid expansion. Mini-grids also face many of the same research challenges as grid infrastructure in terms of understanding causal impacts. More work is needed to understand where, and under what circumstances, mini-grids are a viable electrification solution that can bring economic benefits to the communities they serve.

There is a growing body of literature that focuses on a much wider range of topics related to electricity infrastructure, beyond electricity connections. We contextualise these around the existence of a reliability-consumption loop in which power quality/reliability, consumer behaviour, and the financial health of utilities are highly interconnected, with both supply and demand side processes feeding into the loop. Unreliable or poor quality electricity can discourage investment in appliances and consumer willingness to use electricity, which can in turn affect the financial viability of utilities and their ability to maintain and upgrade infrastructure. These processes also affect, and are affected by, consumer payment behaviour. This self-reinforcing cycle, and the papers that study it explicitly, highlight the importance of considering electricity interventions more comprehensively instead of studying just supply or demand side processes in isolation. We believe that focusing on these system-wide and sometimes indirect effects of interventions is a major opportunity for future research.

Looking to the future, electricity infrastructure decisions will be influenced by pushes towards renewable energy. This shift fundamentally affects how electricity grids operate and has significant implications for electricity access, pollution, reliability, and consequently, for the reliability-consumption loop as a whole. In order to integrate intermittent renewable sources (i.e. wind and solar), there will likely be a need for considerable investment in grid modernisation, storage, and more advanced demand-side management to ensure electricity quality and reliability meet engineering standards. This will be a major challenge in LMICs that are rich in renewable resources and have rapidly growing electricity demand, but where the sector faces major financial constraints. There should be research that considers these challenges and opportunities specifically in LMIC settings in order to help these countries avoid scenarios where reliability issues are exacerbated by renewable integration. Emerging digital and smart grid technologies have the potential to help accelerate research on the modernisation of the grid as renewable generation grows.

From a policy perspective, electrification efforts should be designed to account for much more than just access alone. Ensuring that the power provided is reliable, high quality, and affordable to customers is equally important for economic growth and development. Technological advances in metering, devices enabling real-time monitoring, and automated demand response systems may improve both the reliability of electricity service and the financial health of utilities by reducing both personnel costs and bill non-payment, improving demand prediction, and permitting pricing to be tailored accordingly. While these technologies are being piloted in some LMICs, their use is still not widespread. As these products are increasingly deployed, researchers have an opportunity to measure their impacts. Policies and technologies aimed at improving cost recovery for utilities through interventions such as theft prevention measures and tariff reforms could be critical.

As demand for electricity grows across the globe, electricity infrastructure expansion and upkeep will be increasingly important to policy conversations. The future of electricity infrastructure will be shaped by a convergence of technological advancements, policy innovations, and evolving and growing patterns of demand. Methodological innovations, new sources of data, and increased collaboration over long-term research projects will be essential in creating effective policies that are well targeted to meet the needs of future populations.

Table 1: Examples of Electrification Interventions and Outcomes Studied

Expanding access
Labor market outcomesDinkelman (2011); Grogan & Sadanand (2013); Lipscomb et al. (2013); Van de Walle et al. (2017); Akpandjar & Kitchens (2017); Fetter & Usmani (2024); Meeks et al. (2025)
Household economic outcomesKhandker et al. (2014); Chakravorty et al. (2016); Aklin et al. (2017); Lee et al. (2020a); Burlig & Preonas (2024); Petrusevich (2025)
EducationKhandker et al. (2013); Aklin et al. (2017); Akpandjar & Kitchens (2017); Lee et al. (2020a); Koima (2024); Petrusevich (2025); 
Consumption levels/WTPLee et al. (2020a); Masselus et al. (2024)
HealthBarron & Torero (2017)
Firm outcomesKassem (2024)
Economic developmentLipscomb et al. (2013); Mensah & Traore (2024); Selod et al. (2024)
Off-gridAklin et al. (2017); Meeks et al. (2025); Petrusevich (2025)
Public infrastructureKoima (2024)
Complementary infrastructureMensah & Traore (2024); Selod et al. (2024)
Supply - Energy Mix & Expansion of Generation Infrastructure
Investments in renewablesRyan (2022); Gonzalez et al. (2023)
HealthGupta & Spears (2017); Cropper et al. (2021); Adhvaryu et al. (2023)
Supply - Infrastructural Upgrades
Utility revenue recoveryJack & Smith (2020); Burgess et al. (2022); Ahmad et al. (2024)
Consumer payment behaviorJack & Smith (2020); Burgess et al. (2022); Ahmad et al. (2024)
Consumption levelsJack & Smith (2020); Meeks et al. (2023)
Quality/reliabilityAhmad et al. (2024); Berkouwer et al. (2024)
Investments in energy efficiencyMeeks et al. (2023)
Supply & Demand - Reliability
Firm productivityFisher-Vanden et al. (2015); Allcott et al. (2016); Cole et al. (2018); Fried & Lagakos (2023); Guo et al. (2023)
Consumption levelsKhanna & Rowe (2024); Mugyenyi (2024)
Appliance purchasesKhanna & Rowe (2024); Mugyenyi (2024)
Health/pollution levelsBudlender (2024); Lin & Kassem (2025)
Demand - Pricing
Consumption levelsMcRae & Meeks (2016); Alberini et al. (2022)
Elasticity of demand / understanding of price changesMcRae & Meeks (2016)
Demand - Energy Efficiency
Investment in energy efficiencyDavis & Gertler (2015); Toledo (2016); Ryan (2018); Carranza & Meeks (2021); Beattie et al. (2022)
Consumption levelsDavis & Gertler (2015); Carranza & Meeks (2021)
ReliabilityCarranza & Meeks (2021)
Political Priorities
Utility lossesMin & Golden (2014)
Consumption levelsMahadevan (2024)

References

Abeberese, A B (2017), "Electricity cost and firm performance: Evidence from India", Review of Economics and Statistics, 99(5): 839–852.

Adhvaryu, A, T Molina, A Nyshadham, J Tamayo, and N Torres (2023), "The health costs of dirty energy: Evidence from the capacity market in Colombia", Journal of Development Economics, 164: 103116.

Ahmad, T and D Zhang (2020), "A critical review of comparative global historical energy consumption and future demand: The story told so far", Energy Reports, 6: 1973–1991.

Ahmad, H, A Ali, R Meeks, and Z Wang (2024), "Down to the wire: Leveraging technology to improve electric utility cost recovery", American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, forthcoming.

Ahmad, H, A Ali, R Meeks, and Z Wang (2025), "Turning up the heat: Electricity infrastructure, temperature, and household response in Pakistan", Working paper.

Aklin, M, P Bayer, S P Harish, and J Urpelainen (2017), "Does basic energy access generate socioeconomic benefits? A field experiment with off-grid solar power in India", Science Advances, 3(5): e1602153.

Alby, P, J-J Dethier, and S Straub (2013), "Firms operating under electricity constraints in developing countries", World Bank Economic Review, 27(1): 109–132.

Alberini, A, L Bezhanishvili, and M Ščasný (2022), "'Wild' tariff schemes: Evidence from the Republic of Georgia", Energy Economics, 110: 106030.

Alberini, A, E Steinbuks, and G Timilsina (2022), "How valuable is the reliability of residential electricity supply in low-income countries? Evidence from Nepal", Energy Journal, 43(4): 1–26.

Aliu, I (2020), "Energy efficiency in postpaid-prepaid metered homes: Analyzing effects of socio-economic, housing, and metering factors in Lagos, Nigeria", Energy Efficiency, 13(5): 853–869.

Allcott, H, A Collard-Wexler, and S D O’Connell (2016), "How do electricity shortages affect industry? Evidence from India", American Economic Review, 106(3): 587–624.

Asif, M H, T Zhongfu, M Irfan, B Ahmad, and M Ali (2023), "Assessing eco-label knowledge and sustainable consumption behavior in energy sector of Pakistan: An environmental sustainability paradigm", Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30(14): 41319–41332.

Auffhammer, M (2014), "Cooling China: The weather dependence of air conditioner adoption", Frontiers of Economics in China, 9: 70–84.

Aziz, N, A Raza, H Sui, and Z Zhang (2024), "Empowering women for embracing energy-efficient appliances: Unraveling factors and driving change in Pakistan’s residential sector", Applied Energy, 353: 122156.

Bajo-Buenestado, R (2021), "The effect of blackouts on household electrification status: Evidence from Kenya", Energy Economics, 94: 105067.

Barreca, A, K Clay, O Deschenes, M Greenstone, and J S Shapiro (2016), "Adapting to climate change: The remarkable decline in the US temperature-mortality relationship over the twentieth century", Journal of Political Economy, 124(1): 105–159.

Barron, M and M Torero (2017), "Household electrification and indoor air pollution", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 86: 81–92.

Baskaran, T, B Min, and Y Uppal (2015), "Election cycles and electricity provision: Evidence from a quasi-experiment with Indian special elections", Journal of Public Economics, 126: 64–73.

Bayer, P, R Kennedy, J Yang, and J Urpelainen (2020), "The need for impact evaluation in electricity access research", Energy Policy, 137: 111099.

Beattie, G, I Ding, and A La Nauze (2022), "Is there an energy efficiency gap in China? Evidence from an information experiment", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 115: 102713.

Berkouwer, S B, P E Biscaye, M Mikdash, S L Puller, and C D Wolfram (2024), "Voltage quality and economic activity", Working paper, Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.

Beyene, A D, M Jeuland, S Sebsibie, S Hassen, A Mekonnen, T H Meles, S K Pattanayak, and T Klug (2022), "Pre-paid meters and household electricity use behaviors: Evidence from Addis Ababa, Ethiopia", Energy Policy, 170: 113251.

Bhattacharya, S and U R Patel (2008), "The power sector in India: An inquiry into the efficacy of the reform process", India Policy Forum, 4(1): 211–283.

Bhorat, H and T Köhler (2025), "Watts happening to work? The labour market effects of South Africa’s electricity crisis", Energy Economics, 142: 108119.

Bigerna, S, P Choudhary, N K Jain, S Micheli, and P Polinori (2024), "An empirical investigation of the Indian households’ willingness to pay to avoid power outages", Energy Policy, 184: 113883.

Biardeau, L T, L W Davis, P Gertler, and C Wolfram (2019), "Heat exposure and global air conditioning", Nature Sustainability, 3(1): 25–28.

Budlender, J (2024), "Surviving in the dark: The mortality effects of reducing rolling blackouts", WIDER Working paper.

Burgess, R, M Greenstone, N Ryan, and A Sudarshan (2020), "The consequences of treating electricity as a right", Journal of Economic Perspectives, 34(1): 145–169.

Burgess, R, M Greenstone, N Ryan, and A Sudarshan (2025), "The global electrification frontier and climate change", Warwick economics research papers series.

Burlig, F and L Preonas (2024), "Out of the darkness and into the light? Development effects of rural electrification", Journal of Political Economy, 132(9): 2937–2971.

Callaway, B and P H Sant’Anna (2021), "Difference-in-differences with multiple time periods", Journal of Econometrics, 225(2): 200–230.

Canning, D (1998), "A database of world stocks of infrastructure, 1950–95", World Bank Economic Review, 12(3): 529–547.

Carranza, E and R Meeks (2021), "Energy efficiency and electricity reliability", Review of Economics and Statistics, 103(3): 461–475.

Chakravorty, U and M Pelli (2022), "Electrification and development: Empirical evidence on the effect of electricity provision on household welfare", in Environmental Economics in Developing Countries, 109–122.

Chakravorty, U, K Emerick, and M-L Ravago (2016), "Lighting up the last mile: The benefits and costs of extending electricity to the rural poor", Resources for the Future Discussion paper, 16–22.

Chatterjee, E (2018), "The politics of electricity reform: Evidence from West Bengal, India", World Development, 104: 128–139.

Chaurey, R and D T Le (2022), "Infrastructure maintenance and rural economic activity: Evidence from India", Journal of Public Economics, 214: 104725.

Chen, H, L Jin, M Wang, L Guo, and J Wu (2023), "How will power outages affect the national economic growth: Evidence from 152 countries", Energy Economics, 126: 107055.

Clasen, T F, A Pillarisetti, A M Gill-Wiehl, L Kwong, M Daouda, and D M Kammen (2024), "Revisiting the role of LPG in expanding energy access", Center for Open Science, Working paper.

Cole, M A, R J Elliott, G Occhiali, and E Strobl (2018), "Power outages and firm performance in Sub-Saharan Africa", Journal of Development Economics, 134: 150–159.

Comello, S D, S J Reichelstein, A Sahoo, and T S Schmidt (2017), "Enabling mini-grid development in rural India", World Development, 93: 94–107.

Cropper, M, R Cui, S Guttikunda, N Hultman, P Jawahar, Y Park, X Yao, and X-P Song (2021), "The mortality impacts of current and planned coal-fired power plants in India", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(5): e2017936118.

Davis, L W and P J Gertler (2015), "Contribution of air conditioning adoption to future energy use under global warming", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112(19): 5962–5967.

Davis, L W, A Fuchs, and P Gertler (2014), "Cash for coolers: Evaluating a large-scale appliance replacement program in Mexico", American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 6(4): 207–238.

Davis, L, P Gertler, S Jarvis, and C Wolfram (2021), "Air conditioning and global inequality", Global Environmental Change, 69: 102299.

Davis, L W, S Martinez, and B Taboada (2020), "How effective is energy-efficient housing? Evidence from a field trial in Mexico", Journal of Development Economics, 143: 102390.

Day, E (2020), "Moving beyond energy access – the challenge and impact of unreliable electricity in emerging economies", Technical Report, Energy and Economic Growth Energy Insight.

De Cian, E, G Falchetta, F Pavanello et al. (2025), "The impact of air conditioning on residential electricity consumption across world countries", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, forthcoming.

Deutschmann, J W, A Postepska, and L Sarr (2021), "Measuring willingness to pay for reliable electricity: Evidence from Senegal", World Development, 138: 105209.

Dinkelman, T (2011), "The effects of rural electrification on employment: New evidence from South Africa", American Economic Review, 101(7): 3078–3108.

Dow, E F (1937), "Progress of rural electrification", Journal of Land & Public Utility Economics, 13(2): 211–213.

Erdman, H (1930), "Some social and economic aspects of rural electrification", Journal of Farm Economics, 12(2): 311–319.

Energy Sector Management Assistance Program (2022), "Mini grids for half a billion people: Market outlook and handbook for decision makers", World Bank.

Fetter, T R and F Usmani (2024), "Fracking, farmers, and rural electrification in India", Journal of Development Economics, 170: 103308.

Fisher-Vanden, K, E T Mansur, and Q J Wang (2015), "Electricity shortages and firm productivity: Evidence from China’s industrial firms", Journal of Development Economics, 114: 172–188.

Fowlie, M, Y Khaitan, C Wolfram, and D Wolfson (2018), "Solar microgrids and remote energy access: How weak incentives can undermine smart technology", Economics of Energy and Environmental Policy, 8(1).

Fowlie, M and R Meeks (2021), "The economics of energy efficiency in developing countries", Review of Environmental Economics and Policy, 15(2).

Fried, S and D Lagakos (2023), "Electricity and firm productivity: A general-equilibrium approach", American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 15(4): 67–103.

Gertler, P J, O Shelef, C D Wolfram, and A Fuchs (2016), "The demand for energy-using assets among the world’s rising middle classes", American Economic Review, 106(6): 1366–1401.

Gonzales, L E, K Ito, and M Reguant (2023), "The investment effects of market integration: Evidence from renewable energy expansion in Chile", Econometrica, 91(5): 1659–1693.

Gould, C F, M L Bejarano, B De La Cuesta, D W Jack, S B Schlesinger, A Valarezo, and M Burke (2023), "Climate and health benefits of a transition from gas to electric cooking", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 120(34): e2301061120.

Grogan, L and A Sadanand (2013), "Rural electrification and employment in poor countries: Evidence from Nicaragua", World Development, 43: 252–265.

Guo, D, Q Li, P Liu, X Shi, and J Yu (2023), "Power shortage and firm performance: Evidence from a Chinese city power shortage index", Energy Economics, 119: 106593.

Gupta, A and D Spears (2017), "Health externalities of India's expansion of coal plants: Evidence from a national panel of 40,000 households", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 86: 262–276.

Hashemi, M (2021), "The economic value of unsupplied electricity: Evidence from Nepal", Energy Economics, 95: 105124.

Hassen, S, A D Beyene, M Jeuland, A Mekonnen, T H Meles, S Sebsibie, T Klug, S K Pattanayak, and M A Toman (2022), "Effect of electricity price reform on households’ electricity consumption in urban Ethiopia", Utilities Policy, 79: 101445.

IRENA and World Health Organization (2023), "Energizing health: Accelerating electricity access in health-care facilities", World Health Organization.

Jack, B K and G Smith (2020), "Charging ahead: Prepaid metering, electricity use, and utility revenue", American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 12(2): 134–168.

Jacome, V, N Klugman, C Wolfram, B Grunfeld, D Callaway, and I Ray (2019), "Power quality and modern energy for all", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(33): 16308–16313.

Jeuland, M, T R Fetter, Y Li, S K Pattanayak, F Usmani, R A Bluffstone, C Chávez, H Girardeau, S Hassen, and P Jagger (2021), "Is energy the golden thread? A systematic review of the impacts of modern and traditional energy use in low- and middle-income countries", Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 135: 110406.

Jimenez, E (1995), "Human and physical infrastructure: Public investment and pricing policies in developing countries", Handbook of Development Economics, 3: 2773–2843.

Jimenez, R (2017), "Development effects of rural electrification", Policy Brief No. IDB-PB-261, Inter-American Development Bank.

Karumba, M and E Muchapondwa (2018), "The impact of microhydro electricity on household welfare indicators", Energy Efficiency, 11(3): 663–681.

Kassem, D (2024), "Does electrification cause industrial development? Grid expansion and firm turnover in Indonesia", Journal of Development Economics, 167: 103234.

Khanna, S and K Rowe (2024), "The long-run value of electricity reliability in India", Resource and Energy Economics, 77: 101425.

Khanna, S, R Martin, and M Muuls (2024), "Shifting household power demand across time: Incentives and automation", Working paper.

Khandker, S R, D F Barnes, and H A Samad (2013), "Welfare impacts of rural electrification: A panel data analysis from Vietnam", Economic Development and Cultural Change, 61(3): 659–692.

Khandker, S R, H A Samad, R Ali, and D F Barnes (2014), "Who benefits most from rural electrification? Evidence in India", Energy Journal, 35(2): 75–96.

Klug, T W, A D Beyene, T H Meles, M A Toman, S Hassen, M Hou, B Klooss, A Mekonnen, and M Jeuland (2022), "A review of impacts of electricity tariff reform in Africa", Energy Policy, 170: 113226.

Koima, J (2024), "School electrification and academic outcomes in rural Kenya", Journal of Development Economics, 166: 103178.

Lee, K, E Miguel, and C Wolfram (2020a), "Does household electrification supercharge economic development?", Journal of Economic Perspectives, 34(1): 122–144.

Lee, K, E Miguel, and C Wolfram (2020b), "Experimental evidence on the economics of rural electrification", Journal of Political Economy, 128(4): 1523–1565.

Lewis, J and E Severnini (2020), "Short-and long-run impacts of rural electrification: Evidence from the historical rollout of the US power grid", Journal of Development Economics, 143: 102412.

Lipscomb, M, A M Mobarak, and T Barham (2013), "Development effects of electrification: Evidence from the topographic placement of hydropower plants in Brazil", American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5(2): 200–231.

Lin, Y and D Kassem (2025), "The environmental cost of power outages: Evidence from Delhi", Journal of Public Economics, 242: 105289.

Mahadevan, M (2024a), "The price of power: Costs of political corruption in Indian electricity", American Economic Review, 114(10): 3314–3344.

Mahadevan, M (2024b), "You get what you pay for: Electricity quality and firm response", Working paper.

Mahadevan, M, R McCord, R Meeks, and M Pradhananga (2025), "Understanding the effects of infrastructure upgrades on household behavior and utility revenue: Evidence from smart meters in Kathmandu, Nepal", Working paper.

Masselus, L, J Ankel-Peters, G Gonzalez Sutil, V Modi, J Mugyenyi, A Munyehirwe, N Williams, and M Sievert (2024), "10 years after: Long-term adoption of electricity in rural Rwanda", Ruhr Economic Papers No. 3969732611.

McRae, S (2024), "Efficiency and equity effects of electricity metering: Evidence from Colombia", SSRN Working Paper.

McRae, S (2015), "Infrastructure quality and the subsidy trap", American Economic Review, 105(1): 35–66.

McRae, S and R Meeks (2016), "Price perception and electricity demand with nonlinear tariffs", Working paper.

McRae, S and F A Wolak (2021), "Retail pricing in Colombia to support the efficient deployment of distributed generation and electric stoves", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 110: 102541.

Meeks, R (2018), "Property rights and water access: Evidence from land titling in rural Peru", World Development, 102: 345–357.

Meeks, R C, A Omuraliev, R Isaev, and Z Wang (2023), "Impacts of electricity quality improvements: Experimental evidence on infrastructure investments", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 120: 102838.

Meeks, R C and A Pokhrel (2024), "The economics of electricity and development: Planning for growth and a changing climate", Annual Review of Resource Economics, 16: 323–347.

Meeks, R C, H Thompson, and Z Wang (2025), "Decentralized renewable energy to grow manufacturing? Evidence from microhydro mini-grids in Nepal", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 130: 103092.

Meles, T H, A Mekonnen, A D Beyene, S Hassen, S K Pattanayak, S Sebsibie, T Klug, and M Jeuland (2021), "Households’ valuation of power outages in major cities of Ethiopia: An application of stated preference methods", Energy Economics, 102: 105527.

Mensah, J T (2024), "Jobs! Electricity shortages and unemployment in Africa", Journal of Development Economics, 167: 103231.

Mensah, J T and N Traore (2024), "Infrastructure quality and FDI inflows: Evidence from the arrival of high-speed internet in Africa", World Bank Economic Review, 38(1): 1–23.

Miles, S B, M G Hickman, G Flaspohler, M Bariya, J Mughuma, and D Kammen (2023), "Beyond access: Measuring power quality issues at 27 healthcare facilities in the DRC", International Energy Workshop Conference Paper.

Min, B and M Golden (2014), "Electoral cycles in electricity losses in India", Energy Policy, 65: 619–625.

Moore, N, D Glandon, J Tripney, T Kozakiewicz, S Shisler, J Eyres, and A Perdana (2020), "Effects of access to electricity interventions on socio-economic outcomes in low- and middle-income countries", 3IE Report, International Initiative for Impact Evaluation.

Mugyenyi, J, G G Sutil, and V Modi (2024), "Electricity consumption: The role of grid reliability in appliance ownership and usage in Rwanda", CEEP Working Paper No. 33.

NewsClick (2023), "TN: CPI(M) launches campaign against smart meters, urges state govt to abandon project", Reported by Sruti M.D., NewsClick.

Pattanayak, S K, M Jeuland, J J Lewis, F Usmani, N Brooks, V Bhojvaid, A Kar, L Lipinski, L Morrison, and O Patange (2019), "Experimental evidence on promotion of electric and improved biomass cookstoves", Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(27): 13282–13287.

Peters, J and M Sievert (2016), "Impacts of rural electrification revisited–the African context", Journal of Development Effectiveness, 8(3): 327–345.

Petrusevich, M (2024), "Powering progress: Assessing the impacts of solar mini-grids on energy access and human capital accumulation in India", Working paper.

Pueyo, A and S DeMartino (2018), "The impact of solar mini-grids on Kenya’s rural enterprises", Energy for Sustainable Development, 45: 28–37.

Puzzolo, E, D Pope, D Stanistreet, E A Rehfuess, and N G Bruce (2016), "Clean fuels for resource-poor settings: A systematic review of barriers and enablers to adoption and sustained use", Environmental Research, 146: 218–234.

Randazzo, T, F Pavanello, and E De Cian (2023), "Adaptation to climate change: Air-conditioning and the role of remittances", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 120: 102818.

Ratledge, N, G Cadamuro, B de la Cuesta, M Stigler, and M Burke (2022), "Using machine learning to assess the livelihood impact of electricity access", Nature, 611(7936): 491–495.

Roth, J, P H Sant’Anna, A Bilinski, and J Poe (2023), "What’s trending in difference-in-differences? A synthesis of the recent econometrics literature", Journal of Econometrics, 235(2): 2218–2244.

Ryan, N (2018), "Energy productivity and energy demand: Experimental evidence from Indian manufacturing plants", NBER Working Paper No. 24619.

Ryan, N (2020), "Contract enforcement and productive efficiency: Evidence from the bidding and renegotiation of power contracts in India", Econometrica, 88(2): 383–424.

Ryan, N (2022), "Holding up green energy: Counterparty risk in the Indian solar power market", Working paper.

Selod, H, J Steinbuks, I Trotter, and B Blankespoor (2024), "Infrastructure complementarities and local economic growth: Evidence from electrification and highway construction in Brazil", World Bank.

Steinbuks, J and V Foster (2010), "When do firms generate? Evidence on in-house electricity supply in Africa", Energy Economics, 32(3): 505–514.

Stern, D I, P J Burke, and S B Bruns (2019), "The impact of electricity on economic development: A macroeconomic perspective", EEG State of Knowledge Paper No. 1.1.

Sun, L and S Abraham (2021), "Estimating dynamic treatment effects in event studies with heterogeneous treatment effects", Journal of Econometrics, 225(2): 175–199.

Times of India (2024), "BEST puts on hold smart meter installation in city", Times of India, available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/mumbais-best-halts-smart-meter-installations-amid-public-outcry/articleshow/116148094.cms.

The Hindu (2024), "RJD to protest against smart meters from October 1", reported by Amit Bhelari, The Hindu, available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/rjd-to-protest-against-smart-meters-from-october-1/article67345678.ece.

The Indian Express (2024), "Why people in Gujarat are unhappy with new smart meters", reported by Aditi Raja, The Indian Express, available at: https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/gujarat-unhappy-smart-meters-9349912/.

Toledo, C (2016), "Do environmental messages work on the poor? Experimental evidence from Brazilian favelas", Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists, 3(1): 37–83.

Van de Walle, D, M Ravallion, V Mendiratta, and G Koolwal (2017), "Long-term gains from electrification in rural India", World Bank Economic Review, 31(2): 385–411.

Wolfram, C (2012), "How will energy demand develop in the developing world?", Journal of Economic Perspectives, 26(1): 119–138.

World Bank (2024), "The critical link: Empowering utilities for the energy transition", World Bank, Washington DC.

World Bank (2025a), "Mission 300 is powering Africa", available at: https://www.worldbank.org/en/programs/energizing-africa/faq2.

World Bank and ESMAP (2025b), "Utility Performance and Behavior Today (UPBEAT)", Dataset, available at: https://utilityperformance.energydata.info.

Xiao, Z, J Gao, Z Wang, Z Yin, and L Xiang (2022), "Power shortage and firm productivity: Evidence from the World Bank Enterprise Survey", Energy, 247: 123479.

Previous Chapter
Off-grid electricity infrastructure

Contact VoxDev

If you have questions, feedback, or would like more information about this article, please feel free to reach out to the VoxDev team. We’re here to help with any inquiries and to provide further insights on our research and content.

Contact us